Company proposes a change
Publish a clear, dated summary and a comparison of old versus new terms.
Users get paid when the terms change.
Your time has value. Your legal exposure has a cost. When companies impose new terms, users deserve compensation to review them — in cash, credits, or rebates.
Make policy changes visible, dated, and comparable.
Cash, service credits, or meaningful product rebates.
Enough time and tools to review new obligations.
Return imposed review costs to the company.
A company-initiated material policy change becomes a compensable event, rather than unpaid work silently transferred to its users.
Publish a clear, dated summary and a comparison of old versus new terms.
Provide an accessible cash payment, account credit, or product rebate for the review burden.
Allow a meaningful review period to read, assess risk, and seek advice.
Accept, reject, or exit with an appropriate refund or remedy. Payment does not equal consent.
Users should see what changed, what it costs them to evaluate the change, what they receive, and what choices remain theirs.
Payment for review is not payment for agreement. The user keeps the right to reject the new terms.
These changes affect how data is used, liability allocation, and dispute resolution. Under the proposed Policy Dividend standard, you receive compensation for reviewing the changes.
Before: Account data used to provide the service.
After: Additional data use proposed for analytics and personalization.
This is a fictional example, not an actual company's terms.
Section 11.2 of Québec's Consumer Protection Act, enacted in 2009, sets conditions on any clause that lets a merchant change a consumer contract unilaterally.
Written clearly and legibly, sent at least 30 days before the change takes effect, with that date and the consumer's rights.
When a clause is amended, the notice sets out the amended clause and the clause as it read before. A brand-new clause is shown on its own.
If the change increases the consumer's obligations or reduces the merchant's, the consumer can refuse it and leave without cost or penalty, until 30 days after it takes effect.
The section provides nothing for the time it takes to read, assess and decide. That is the Policy Dividend.
The section does not apply to variable credit contracts, such as credit cards. Except in open-ended service contracts, essential elements such as the price, the term, or the nature of the goods or services cannot be changed this way at all. An amendment that breaks the section cannot be invoked against the consumer.
A company decides to rewrite its contract. It should bear the resulting review burden rather than treating millions of users' hours as free.
Show each material change in plain language, with original language available for comparison.
Compensate affected users for imposed review time and a defined contractual risk allowance.
Neither payment nor silence automatically means acceptance. Users retain meaningful options to reject and exit.
You cannot unilaterally impose labour on another party, call it consent, and assign that labour a value of zero.
Ten cards. Pick one to post, copy or download.
Hey, come on in. This is Policy Dividend, where users get paid when the terms change.
And listening is free. No account, and no terms to accept. The line we're on lights up as we go.
If somebody you know just clicked, I agree, the share button is at the top. Shameless, I know.
Completely shameless. Let's begin.
Good news! We've updated our terms. There's nothing you need to do.
Nothing? It's forty pages. If I don't read it, you'll say I agreed.
By continuing to use the service, yes. That would be consent.
So there is something to do. Somebody has to read it, work out what it exposes them to, and decide. That's work. And you just assigned it.
We don't pay people to read.
That's the proposal. If a company changes its policies, users get paid.
Paid how much?
As an example, in Canadian dollars. Ninety minutes of review, at one hundred dollars an hour, is one hundred and fifty dollars. Add a fifty dollar allowance for contractual risk. That makes two hundred dollars per user.
We have a million users. That would be two hundred million dollars!
It's a million and a half hours of other people's time. The cost was always there. You just weren't the one carrying it.
And I can move those sliders myself.
All right. Say I play along. What would I actually have to do?
One. Publish a clear, dated summary of the change, with the old terms next to the new ones.
Two. Compensate the review. Cash, an account credit, or a product rebate.
A coupon for ten percent off our premium plan?
Something of real value.
Three. Allow enough time to read, to assess the risk, and to get advice.
Four. Let the user choose. Accept, reject, or exit with a refund or another remedy.
But once I've paid them, they've agreed.
No. You paid for the reading. You didn't buy the answer.
So what lands in my inbox, instead of, we updated our terms?
A notice marked as a material change. It says what moved. How data is used, who carries liability, and how disputes get resolved.
And it says what I get for reading it.
It shows before, and after. Before, account data was used to provide the service. After, it's also used for analytics and personalization.
You make it sound so different when you put them side by side.
It is different. That's why I want them side by side.
And the line that holds it all together. Payment for review is not payment for agreement.
This is a fantasy. No legislature would make me show old wording, or let people walk away for free.
Québec did. Section eleven point two of the Consumer Protection Act, enacted in two thousand and nine. If a contract lets a merchant change it alone, the merchant must give written notice at least thirty days ahead.
When a clause is amended, that notice sets out the amended clause, and the clause as it read before.
And if the change increases the consumer's obligations, or reduces the merchant's, the consumer can refuse and leave, without cost or penalty, up to thirty days after it takes effect.
Surely there are limits.
The section doesn't apply to variable credit, like credit cards. And outside open-ended service contracts, essential terms, like the price, can't be changed this way at all.
So the notice, the comparison and the exit are already law there. What's missing?
Payment. The section provides nothing for the time it takes to read.
The diff and the exit are already law in Québec. The dividend is the missing piece.
So put the cost where the decision was made.
A right to a clear diff, in plain language, with the original available.
A right to compensation, for review time and a defined allowance for risk.
And consent is separate. Neither payment nor silence means yes.
If every change costs me money, I'd only change the terms when it really mattered.
Yes.
And I'd keep it short. Every minute of reading is on my bill.
Now you're getting it.
You cannot unilaterally impose labour on another party, call it consent, and assign that labour a value of zero.
Before you go, one more thing, and yes, it's a plug. That sentence has its own copy button.
There are ten cards just below. Send one to whoever last updated your terms.
Please don't.
One tap each. All free.
And there's plenty more from Feline Union, also free. Thanks for listening.
Every source for this is listed at the end of the page, and every one of them is linked.
This was Policy Dividend. A Feline Union publication.